Nonprofit Founder Exit Plan: Why to Start Planning Yours From Day One
Most founders I know spend their first few years getting their nonprofit off the ground, then keeping it funded, then keeping up with the growth that follows. Almost none of them sit down in the middle of all that and plan how they'll leave. And, I get it. It feels strange, even disloyal, to plan your exit from something you just poured yourself into.
On a recent episode of Nonprofit on the Rocks, host Matt pointed out that he has started 3 nonprofits and is no longer involved in any of them, and that most founders can't do the same because their identity gets wrapped up in the organization. That led us to a question I think every founder should ask early. When do you start planning for succession? My answer is right at the beginning, because the systems and operations you build early are what prepare an organization for the day you leave.
Key Takeaways
Knowing you'll hand your nonprofit over changes how you build.
The systems and operations you build early are what prepare an organization to run without its founder.
Two warning signs that show your nonprofit leans too hard on you.
Why Founder Succession Planning Starts on Day One
It sounds backwards when you've barely started, but knowing you'll eventually hand the organization to someone else changes the way you build it. You start writing down why you make the decisions you make, because the next person will need that context. You build strategy and systems that someone who wasn't in the room can follow, and you explain to the people around you what you do and why, since one day they'll have to do it without you. Founders who skip this early work usually end up doing it in the middle of a crisis, when they're already exhausted and have no time to do it well.
That early work pays off long before you ever leave. An organization that can run without you for a day or two gives you a chance to rest, which most founders never get. Being a founder or an executive director can feel like an impossible job, and so many of us end up burned out from believing the whole world rests on our shoulders. I was one of those founders, and if you're getting close to that point, I wrote about 5 systems to put in place first in Before You Burn Out: 5 Systems Every Nonprofit Founder Needs to Build Now. Preparing for succession is the long-term version of the same idea. You build the organization so it can function when you're not in the room, whether you're gone for an afternoon or for good.
What Happens When a Founder Never Plans Their Exit
Looking back at my first nonprofit, almost everything that went wrong traces to one thing, which is that I never planned for anyone else to take it over. I tried to delegate. I tried to get other people to help with the work, but I didn't build the systems that made it all possible and manageable.
I was good at relationships, and those relationships brought in grants quickly, so we built programs and grew faster than I had prepared for. I had invited friends onto the board without thinking much about what the organization needed from it, and I hadn't built a foundation that would make anything easy to hand off.
Because I was good at what I did, everyone assumed I had it covered and drifted away, and over time the work became mine alone. I wasn't able to explain clearly what I did or what I needed, which meant there was nothing to hand off to anyone, and eventually I burned out. The handoff that followed is the story behind How to Build Systems So Your Nonprofit Doesn't Fall Apart Without You.
Two Warning Signs Your Nonprofit Depends Too Much on You
There were warning signs, and they're easier to catch than I wish I'd known. The first is when your board members can't explain what the organization does. On mine, different board members described the organization in different ways, each building on their own idea of what we were doing, and that told me something had broken in how we communicated internally. When the people closest to you don't know what's happening, they can't speak for you or advocate for you, and they can't tell anyone what you actually do. If you're still building your board, How To Build Your First Board of Directors is where I'd begin.
The second warning sign is that the people around you aren't doing any of the work and you're quietly doing everything. It's easy to believe you can keep that up a while longer, but no matter how long you think you can manage, it isn't sustainable. Both signs point to the same gap, which is that the organization lives in your head and has no structure other people can use.
The Systems and Operations That Prepare a Nonprofit for a Founder Transition
Succession planning gets talked about as a document you write when you're ready to leave, but in my work the preparation happens much earlier, in the systems and operations that decide whether an organization can function without its founder. The two warning signs mentioned earlier point straight at what to build.
The first piece is written-down reasoning. A list of tasks won't carry an organization through a handoff, so capture why you make the choices you make and what the process looks like, from how your board makes decisions to why you chose the programs you did, so someone stepping in can follow your thinking.
The second is shared work. The strongest founders I know delegate and collaborate. They look for a team and community to build alongside. When you're the only person doing the work, nobody else learns how it's done, and nobody else can speak up for the organization either.
The third is a budget with a role someone else could afford to take. When I work with organizations, I have them build a dream budget, because that's where fundraising starts, and the salary belongs in it from the first version, even if you can't pay yourself in year 1 or 2. Knowing the number shows you what you need to raise, and it shapes who can step in after you, because the next person has to be able to live on what you pay them, easily if not lavishly.
Now paying CEOs and Executive Directors comes under a lot of scrutiny. People see the outliers getting paid millions. This is not the case with most organizations. So, when considering how much to pay an Executive Director, I think there are two important measures. One, is it a living wage? Can someone reasonably live on the salary you're paying them? The second is a measure of equity. I like a 5:1 ratio, where the CEO or Executive Director makes no more than 5 times what the lowest-paid team member makes. The test is how much you make relative to your employees. If we're going to fight for CEOs to be paid more, we need to fight to pay our lowest paid employees more too. We got into this further on the episode, and it's worth a listen if you've ever wondered where that line is.
Build Slow, and Build It to Be Handed Off
If I could tell my younger founder self one thing, it would be to build slow. Building slow means putting the systems and operations in place as you go. It means building with intention, and not rushing forward just to get stuff done. It looks like each decision made in a way someone else can follow later, which is what makes it possible to hand an organization over, or to step away for a weekend, without losing what you built. It also means having a team and community behind you. When you rush in alone, you have no one to hand off anything to.
That's why I created the Nonprofit Launch Academy. I spent a year putting every step into one place, with worksheets and templates, from your purpose and legal structure through your board, so you can build your organization right and skip the nights I spent at 3 a.m. with dozens of tabs open trying to work out what was right.
If you're thinking about starting a nonprofit, it gives you the order. If you've already launched, it still applies. It's a great refresher and a way to find the parts of your organization that are thin.
Check out the episode on YouTube.
About Blessed Designs Consulting
Blessed Designs Consulting works with social and environmental justice organizations to build strong, sustainable foundations by clarifying their purpose, strengthening operations, and creating systems that attract funding and support long-term growth.
Comments